ao link

SAIC Comment: Finding a home for innovation

Although innovative ideas can come from anywhere, we need physical spaces to test and develop them for market-readiness. Benedikte Ranum and Sarah Riddle ask: “Does Scotland have enough ‘safe playgrounds’ for trialling aquaculture innovation?”

Linked InXFacebook
lightbulb_concept_AdobeStock_624038570_20250313

There is a common perception that innovation is a single event, a lightbulb moment in the mind of an extraordinary, highly creative individual. The truth is that innovation often is, and should be, part of the everyday fabric of life. It can occur in offices, fabrication yards, homes and farms all over Scotland whenever we imagine a new way of working, a better product or service.

 

But it takes hard work for repeatable, reliable innovation to be firmly embedded into the structure of how we operate – whether as individuals, as businesses, or as a nation.

 

This was discussed some time ago in a Harvard Business Review article on Inspiring Innovation, where interviewee Craig Wynett of Procter & Gamble said: “For innovation to be reliable, it needs to be addressed systematically, like any business issue in which you define the problem and then solve it: What do we want to accomplish, and how? What resources will we need? Who will be on the team? How do we motivate and reward them? And how will we measure success?”

 

These very questions are being asked in a series of conversations taking place right now among Scottish aquaculture stakeholders who are keen to commit to the future of the sector.

 

We know that the landscapes of both innovation and regulation are changing. So how do we make sure that in the midst of these changes, we are creating an environment where innovation can thrive?

 

Based on SAIC’s experience over the past 11 years, we already have some of the answers:

  • Pre-competitive collaboration, finding shared solutions to shared challenges.
  • Seeking input from unusual places and people, not just the “usual suspects”.
  • A sufficiently resourced regulatory system that keeps pace with innovation, reflects commercial realities, and is founded on scientific fact.
  • Facilitated conversations that emphasise common ground rather than reinforcing entrenched positions.
  • Fostering relationships between the public and private sectors where each partner seeks to genuinely understand the other’s pressure points, and where action is valued above good intention.
Benedikte_Ranum_left_and_Sarah_Riddle_20250313
Benedikte Ranum (left) and Sarah Riddle

But as well as the right mindsets and partnerships, we need physical facilities that can provide a breeding ground for innovation. A safe space where new ideas and technologies can be tested. We have RAVIC (the Rural and Veterinary Innovation Centre) in Inverness, the Marine Aquaculture Innovation Centre at Loch Fyne, and NATIH (the National Aquaculture Technology and Innovation Hub) is coming to Stirling – but we know that more is needed.

 

The recommendations of the Scottish Parliament’s Rural Affairs and Islands Committee have been issued, and among many others, the committee “…notes its earlier recommendation calling for the development of dedicated research pens”.

 

The Scottish Government will make its response in due course. In the meantime, we should continue our inclusive, pragmatic and productive conversations about what we – collectively – need to do for the innovators in Scottish aquaculture to succeed.

 

Aquaculture innovation is moving at pace across the globe, and the Scottish sector won’t want to lose any ground. We will need to navigate this ever-changing landscape together, reminding ourselves that, as Thomas Fogarty of Stanford University, said: “One of the hardest things about innovation is getting people to accept that the way they work just might not be the best.”

 

Benedikte Ranum is Knowledge Exchange Manager, SAIC (the Sustainable Aquaculture Innovation Centre) and Sarah Riddle is Head of Research & Innovation, SAIC. 

Linked InXFacebook
Hygiene Operative - Night - Bakkafrost Scotland Limited
CairndowCairndow£22,313.50 to £23,429.18 per annum£22,313.50 to £23,429.18 per annum

Storekeeper - Mowi Scotland
KyleakinKyleakinSalary On ApplicationSalary On Application

Maintenance Engineer (Electrical) - Mowi Scotland
KyleakinKyleakin£36,635 to £43,702 per annum£36,635 to £43,702 per annum

Farm Technician (BDNC) - Mowi Scotland
Argyll & ButeArgyll & Bute£27,236 to £30,504 per annum£27,236 to £30,504 per annum

Assistant Accountant - Mowi Scotland
RosythRosythSalary On ApplicationSalary On Application
Fish Farmer Magazine
IPSO
Facebook
X
Linked In

© 2025 Fish Farmer.